The work spans four volumes and over two thousand pages, the Trattato attempts nothing less than a comprehensive science of society, built on the methods Pareto had absorbed as a trained engineer: empirical observation, mathematical reasoning, and the concept of equilibrium.
Pareto’s starting point is a challenge to the Enlightenment assumption that human beings act primarily on the basis of reason. He argues that most human actions are "non-logical"—not in the sense of being irrational or foolish, but in the sense that the real forces driving them are not the reasons people give for them. Logical actions, where means and ends are connected both in the actor's mind and in objective reality, are largely confined to domains like engineering, science, and economic calculation. In political, social, and religious life, by contrast, people act on the basis of deep sentiments and instincts, and only afterwards construct rational-sounding justifications for what they have done.
To analyse this gap between real motives and stated reasons, Pareto introduces his most distinctive theoretical tools: residues and derivations. Residues are the relatively constant, observable manifestations of underlying sentiments and instincts—though Pareto is careful to insist that residues are not the sentiments themselves, but rather their outward traces, much as a mercury reading is a manifestation of temperature, not the temperature itself. Derivations are the variable, often elaborate intellectual constructions—appeals to authority, tradition, metaphysics, or abstract principle—that people use to justify and rationalise actions whose true roots lie in the residues.
Pareto classifies residues into six main classes. Class I, the instinct for combinations, encompasses the drive toward innovation, experimentation, and the manipulation of ideas and resources—the disposition to combine and recombine elements in new ways. Class II, the persistence of aggregates, represents the conservative impulse: loyalty to family, nation, tradition, and established order. Class III covers the need to manifest sentiments through external activities such as religious ceremonies, political rallies, and festivals. Class IV concerns sociality—the instincts that sustain social discipline, hierarchy, and self-sacrifice for the group. Class V relates to the integrity of the individual and of property, underpinning systems of law and personal honour. Class VI encompasses the sexual instinct and its social manifestations. Throughout the Trattato, Pareto places particular emphasis on the tension between the first two classes—combination and persistence, innovation and tradition—as the fundamental dynamic driving social change.
The final volume of the Trattato brings this psychological framework to bear on political power. Building on ideas he had sketched in his 1900 essay The Rise and Fall of Elites, Pareto argues that all societies are governed by a minority—an elite—and that the composition of this elite is in constant flux. Drawing on Machiavelli, he distinguishes between elites dominated by Class I residues, whom he calls foxes (cunning, innovative, and skilled at manipulation but reluctant to use force), and those dominated by Class II residues, whom he calls lions (conservative, forceful, and committed to tradition and social order). Societies oscillate between periods of fox rule and lion rule. When foxes dominate for too long, their cleverness degenerates into corruption and instability; when lions prevail, their rigidity eventually stifles adaptation. The cycle repeats endlessly—Pareto sees no possibility of permanent progress, only a shifting equilibrium.
Underpinning the entire work is Pareto’s model of society as a system in equilibrium, analogous to a mechanical or thermodynamic system. Social equilibrium is maintained by a balance among countervailing forces—centralization and decentralization of power, economic expansion and contraction, innovation and tradition. Change occurs not through linear progress but through shifts in the relative strength of these forces. When the balance tips too far in one direction, corrective pressures build until the system readjusts—often through the replacement of one elite by another.
The Trattato remains influential and contentious in roughly equal measure. Its framework of residues, derivations, and elite circulation offers a powerful lens for analysing political movements, ideological conflict, and the persistence of inequality. But its legacy is inseparable from its political afterlife: Pareto’s theories of elite rule were embraced by Mussolini and the Italian Fascist movement, with one contemporary observer noting that the Trattato had become, for many fascists, a treatise on government. Scholars continue to debate how far this appropriation was a legitimate reading of Pareto’s ideas and how far it was a selective distortion. Either way, the Trattato stands as a work of formidable intellectual ambition—one that, for better and worse, helped shape the political imagination of the twentieth century.
• Title: The Mind and Society
• Author: Vilfredo Pareto
• Type: Book
• Publisher: n/a
• Publication time: 1916
• Publication place: n/a
Nineteen Eighty-Four
A Moveable Feast (December, 1964)
Ernest Hemingway
The Old Man and the Sea (September 1, 1952)
Ernest Hemingway
The Open Door (1957)
Helen Keller